Why One DHCP Server Is Better Than Many

-

 

Why One DHCP Server Is Better Than Many (Real Network Lessons)

Back when I was managing networks for a small ISP and a hospital, we had two separate DHCP servers: one for internet clients, and another for hospital/internal systems (HIMS). On paper, it seemed clean — different networks, different scopes.

In reality? It was a maintenance nightmare. 😅

The Problem: Multiple DHCPs = More Trouble

Running multiple DHCP servers in the same environment can create:

  • IP conflicts – overlapping ranges can cause devices to fight over addresses.

  • Routing confusion – packets might get lost between networks that don’t talk cleanly.

  • Harder maintenance – every change has to be repeated in multiple scopes.

  • Troubleshooting nightmares – one DHCP gives errors, another works fine… good luck figuring out which.

I suggested a unified DHCP approach 10 years ago, but it wasn’t implemented back then. Fast forward a decade… and they finally did it. Imagine the frustration of seeing your idea work so long after you proposed it! 😅

What “One DHCP” Really Means

Using one DHCP server doesn’t mean putting all devices in the same IP range. It’s about:

  • Centralized control: One server manages all IP leases.

  • Logical segmentation: VLANs or subnets keep different groups of devices isolated.

  • Consistent policies: One source for DNS, gateways, and lease times.

Essentially, centralization + segmentation = simpler, more reliable network.

Why One DHCP Works Better

  1. No IP conflicts – one source of truth for all segments.

  2. Easier troubleshooting – centralized logs and single point of management.

  3. Scalable – add new network segments without deploying new DHCP servers.

  4. Better traffic management – predictable IPs allow QoS and routing rules to be applied consistently.

  5. Consistency – DNS, gateway, and policies are uniform across all segments.

Collision Domains in a One-DHCP Network

A collision domain is the network segment where devices share the same physical medium, meaning data packets could collide if multiple devices transmit at the same time. Proper segmentation reduces collisions and improves network performance.

  • Single DHCP server: Only one device assigns IPs — reduces miscommunication.

  • VLANs / Subnets: Each VLAN acts as its own collision domain, so devices inside VLAN A don’t interfere with VLAN B.

  • Switching: Modern switches enforce this separation automatically — collisions are limited to each VLAN.

Updated Topology


Key Points:

  • Single DHCP Server: Manages all IP pools centrally.

  • Separate VLANs: Each VLAN is its own collision domain.

  • Benefits:

    • No IP conflicts

    • Reduced collisions

    • Centralized management

    • Easier troubleshooting

Implementation Tips (General)

  • Segment networks logically – use VLANs or separate subnets.

  • Set IP pools per segment – each network gets its own range from the central DHCP server.

  • Reserve IPs for critical devices – servers, printers, or medical equipment.

  • Centralize logs and lease tracking – makes troubleshooting faster.

Common Mistakes: Why Multiple DHCP Servers Fail

Even experienced teams sometimes overcomplicate DHCP setups. Here’s what I’ve seen in real networks:

  1. Running separate DHCP servers for each segment → Confusion and IP conflicts.

  2. Not reserving IPs for critical devices → Devices get dynamic IPs, causing system failures.

  3. Multiple DHCP servers in the same domain → Conflicting responses, broken connections.

  4. Resistance to centralization → Duplicated effort, inconsistent policies, harder maintenance.

How One DHCP Solves These Mistakes:

MistakeHow One DHCP Solves It
Separate servers → conflictsSingle source of truth, unique IP pools per VLAN/subnet
No reservations → devices failCentralized reservation table for critical devices
Multiple servers in same domain → IP conflictsSegmented subnets/VLANs with centralized control
Resistance to centralization → duplicated effortSingle server, easier scaling, unified policies

Lesson Learned

  • Complexity doesn’t mean better.

  • Multiple DHCP servers feel “safe” but usually add confusion and wasted effort.

  • One DHCP server with proper segmentation = stable, scalable, low-maintenance network.

Whether it’s a small ISP, a hospital network, or a home lab, ask yourself:
“Can one DHCP server handle this efficiently, with proper segmentation?”
If yes → do it. You’ll save headaches, simplify administration, and make scaling easier.


References:

  • https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/chapter/edited-volume/abs/pii/B9781928994060500060 
  • https://docs.trendmicro.com/en-us/documentation/article/trend-micro-apex-one-patch-3-online-help-dhcp
  • https://community.ruckuswireless.com/t5/RUCKUS-One/Ruckus-One-DHCP-scope-limitations/m-p/96254
  • https://mivilisnet.wordpress.com/2018/05/23/your-dhcp-server-must-be-in-only-one-vlan/

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Suricata on Mikrotik(IDS+IPS) = Part 4 - Configuration of the IPS Part

-
Image
  Configuration Disclaimer:  this one again is only for  ubuntu 18.04  and login as  root  user to be sure Make sure you have a good understanding of the suricata rules before doing this This might cause some disconnection from the site or services you are visiting and even the internet if not properly configured. In the real environment it is best not to run as root user but for the sake of just testing it I opted to run as root configure the following rules on your mikrotik router: /ip firewall filter add action=drop chain=input comment="Block bad actors" src-address-list=Blocked /ip firewall filter add action=drop chain=forward comment="Drop any traffic going to bad actors" dst-address-list=Blocked create a user group with all policies checked except telnet create a user allowing your local addresses with the group you created earlier Lets Start ... 1.      Install PHP         apt install php -y 2.   Navigate...
Read more

Why upload comes first before download

-
Image
Before we dive into why upload comes first, let’s quickly define upload and download in data communication. Upload refers to sending data from your device to a remote server or another device. This happens when you send an email, upload a file to the cloud, or even just request a webpage. Download is the process of receiving data from a remote source to your device. This includes streaming videos, loading webpages, or saving files from the internet. Think of it like a conversation: when you ask someone a question (upload), they respond with an answer (download). The same applies to internet communication—before you can receive data, you must first send a request. Why Upload Comes First in Data Communication Now that we understand uploads and downloads, let’s put it in simple human terms. Imagine you’re having a conversation with a friend: You ask a question (Upload): Before your friend can give you an answer, you first need to say something—whether it’s a question, a request, or a ...
Read more

DHCP for Dummies: How Your Devices Get Online Without You Lifting a Finger

-
Image
DHCP for Dummies: How Your Devices Get Online Without You Lifting a Finger Introduction Ever wondered how your phone, laptop, or smart TV connects to the internet without you having to do anything? One minute you’re tapping "Connect to Wi-Fi," and the next, boom—you’re online. That magic? It’s all thanks to DHCP. DHCP (Dynamic Host Configuration Protocol) is what hands out IP addresses to your devices, kind of like a hotel receptionist giving guests room keys. It’s automatic, invisible, and keeps everything running smoothly—until something breaks. In this guide, you’ll learn: ✔️ What DHCP is (in plain English). ✔️ How it works behind the scenes. ✔️ Why it’s better than manually assigning IP addresses. ✔️ How to fix common DHCP problems without calling IT. By the end, you’ll have a solid grip on DHCP—even if tech stuff usually makes your head hurt. Let’s go! --- What is DHCP? (The No-Nonsense Explanation) Okay, imagine you walk into a hotel. You don’t pick a room or set up a k...
Read more